Comparison

Clerkcat vs. Excel Spreadsheets

Why purpose-built visitor management beats manual spreadsheet tracking.

No credit card required • 14-day free trial

Excel is the Swiss Army knife of business software. It can do almost anything—including visitor tracking. Many organizations graduate from paper sign-in sheets to Excel, creating spreadsheets where staff manually enter visitor information. It's a step up from paper, but it's still a manual process bolted onto a tool designed for something else entirely.

The fundamental problem with Excel for visitor management is data entry. Someone has to type in every visitor's information, either during check-in (which slows everything down) or afterward (which means delays and potential errors). Staff get busy, entries get missed, and your "complete" visitor log develops gaps.

Then there's the single-point-of-failure issue. Your visitor spreadsheet lives on someone's computer. If they're out sick, or if that computer dies, or if the file gets corrupted, you've lost your data. Sharing access and maintaining version control creates its own headaches.

Clerkcat eliminates these problems by automating data capture. Visitors enter their own information on a tablet—no staff typing required. The data goes directly to the cloud, accessible from anywhere, backed up automatically. You get Excel's export capabilities without Excel's maintenance burden.

For organizations that have outgrown paper but aren't ready for enterprise visitor management systems, Clerkcat occupies the sweet spot: powerful enough to solve real problems, simple enough to actually use.

Feature Comparison

FeatureClerkcatExcel Spreadsheets
Data entrySelf-service by visitorsManual staff entry
Real-time accessInstant cloud syncFile sharing delays
Data backupAutomatic cloud backupManual backup required
Multi-user accessUnlimited team membersVersion control issues
Check-in notificationsAutomatic host alertsNot possible
ReportingBuilt-in dashboardsManual chart creation
Mobile accessFull mobile supportLimited mobile editing
Data validationEnforced field typesInconsistent entries

Why Choose Clerkcat

Zero manual data entry

Visitors check themselves in. Staff time is freed for more important work.

Always accessible, always backed up

Cloud-based storage means no lost files, no version conflicts, no single point of failure.

Purpose-built features

Host notifications, visitor badges, check-out tracking—features you'd have to hack together in Excel.

Consistent data quality

Required fields and validation ensure complete, usable records every time.

Ready-made reports

Export visitor data without building formulas or pivot tables. Reports are just a click away.

Excel Spreadsheets Limitations

Manual entry is a bottleneck

Someone has to type every visitor's information. When staff get busy, data quality suffers.

No real-time capabilities

Excel can't notify hosts when visitors arrive or show who's currently checked in.

Version control nightmares

Multiple people editing the same spreadsheet leads to conflicts, overwrites, and lost data.

Requires Excel expertise

Building useful reports means understanding formulas, pivot tables, and charts.

Security and access challenges

Controlling who can view or edit visitor data is difficult with shared files.

Is Clerkcat Right for You?

Clerkcat is the better choice if any of these apply:

  • Organizations where staff are spending time on manual data entry
  • Teams experiencing version control or file access issues
  • Anyone who wants host notifications when visitors arrive
  • Places that need consistent, reliable visitor records
  • Organizations that want visitor analytics without Excel expertise

The Bottom Line

Excel is great for many things, but visitor management isn't one of them. Clerkcat does what would take hours of manual work in Excel—automatically, reliably, and without requiring any spreadsheet skills.

Ready to Switch?

Start your 14-day free trial today. No credit card required.

  • Unlimited kiosks per location
  • Unlimited visitors
  • Unlimited team members
$49/mo

per location